|Season 4, Episode 2|
|Air date||October 12, 2013|
|Written by||Harold Hayes Jr. & Craig S. Phillips|
|Directed by||Neill Fearnley|
Kate, a snooty homecoming queen, Halftime, a lovable, but dim-witted jock, and Audrey, an apathetic Goth girl, are stuck in detention for unknown reasons, but when Kate goes missing and strange images and noises begin haunting them, Audrey and Halftime soon realize that their after-school punishment is from a higher power, who wants them to atone for a homecoming court voting scandal and a parade accident that claimed all of their lives.
- Madeline Carroll as Aubrey
- Madison Desjarlais as Kate Carter
- Stephen Dimopoulos as Janitor
- Casey Dubois as Halftime
- Nicholas Ekren as Gabe
- Nico McEown as Spirited Teen
- David Pearson as Mr. Kane
- This episode was originally supposed to be aired during season 3.
- This is Madeline Carroll's second time appearing since in the season 1 episode "Nightmare Inn".
- This is Madison Desjarlais' third time appearing since in the season 1 episode "Lights Out" and the season 2 episode "Headshot".
- This is Casey Dubois' second time appearing since in the season 1 two-part episode "Really You".
- This is Nico McEown's second time appearing since in the season 1 episode "Alien Candy".